The Most Dog Friendly Community Online
Join Dog Forum to Discuss Breeds, Training, Food and More

Long But Very Important

digzoils

New Member
Registered
Messages
77
Reaction score
0
Points
0

Join our free community today.

Connect with other like-minded dog lovers!

Login or Register
As some of you know we are activly fighting the fluoridation of drinking water here in the UK :rant: :rant: . If after reading this you want to join the fight or just want more info please PM me.

Paul

****************************************************************

NPWA BULLETIN

Dogs, Cats, Osteosarcoma, Dysplasia and pet food fluoride content

George Glasser

The recent cover-up scandal about osteosarcoma and drinking water

fluoridation brought to mind research I had done several years ago into

canine osteosarcoma which is fairly common among certain breeds of dogs and

cats.

Because of the association between osteosarcoma and drinking water

fluoridation, I contacted people who's dogs developed the cancer to see if

the lived in fluoridated areas, but there was not even a credible anecdotal

connection. It appeared to be a universal problem. I dropped the

investigation until the new flap came up about fluoride and osteosarcoma

and I decided to take a fresh look at the issue again.

OSTEOSARCOMA is the most common bone cancer in humans, cats and dogs.

Osteosarcoma mostly occurs in male humans, dogs and cats.

In dogs, the disease is more frequently seen in larger breeds such as

rottweilers, greyhounds, golden retrievers, etc.

Recent studies have also shown that osteosarcoma is also more common in

taller people.

Osteosarcoma accounts for 85% of all primary bone tumours in dogs, and in

the US - 8,000-10,000

dogs per year in U.S develop osteosarcoma

(http://www.vetmed.lsu.edu/oncology/osteosar.htm).

In cats, osteosarcoma accounts for 70% of primary bone tumours.

In humans, about 5 children out of a million develop osteosarcoma each

year. Osteosarcoma accounts for five percent of all primary bone tumours in

children.

Osteosarcoma is the most common type of bone cancer/tumours seen in humans,

dogs and cats.

CONNECTING THE DOTS:

If fluoride were possibly a factor - how did the animals get a sufficient

does in their diet? My research suggested that it was arbitrary and not

associated with drinking water fluoridation if fluoride were a factor. The

only other possibility was in their food.

It took nothing more than an Internet search using "fluoride content + dog

food" and there it was:

A low-fluoride commercial dog food contains 40 - 60 parts per million of

fluoride.

A high-fluoride dog food can contain up to 460 parts per million of

fluoride (Marks TA, J Toxicol Environ Health. 1984;14(5-6):707-14).

"A 1971 study at the University of Montana found the average level of

fluoride in leading pet foods to be 11 to 193 ppm, with the highest found

in canned pet food. If your dog weighs 100 pounds this translates to a

daily consumption of 21 to 368 milligrams of fluoride from commercial food.

The government upper daily limit of 2.5 milligrams of fluoride is said to

be safe for children over three years of age. The Montana researchers found

that fluoride accumulates in pet's bones. 84 to 1535 milligrams of fluoride

was found in dog's leg bones. 74 to 1,190 milligrams was found in the bones

of cats, and it increased with age." http://www.leaflady.org/pethealth.htm.

Investigating further, some lower grade dog foods MAY CONTAIN even more -

up to 2,000 parts per million of fluoride.

Interestingly, the only study I could find about dogs, osteosarcoma and

fluoride was one where they were investigating fluoridated drinking water -

Apparently, the researchers, not realising that dogs may already be

consuming several hundred milligrams of fluoride per day in their food;

tens - hundreds of times more that the recommended dose for humans of 1.0

milligram per day.

While there are fairly strict regulations about how much fluoride can be in

the food of farm animals, the guidelines for pet foods are fluid. I could

find no research for "safe fluoride levels" for cats and dogs.

There is no fluoride intake criteria for pet dogs and cats - it is all

based on ASSUMPTION and not science.

The reason that pets and dietary fluoride intake have been totally

neglected is that pets do not represent an agricultural cash commodity. For

instance, daily fluoride intake for breeding farm animals and dairy cows

are lower than for animals raised for slaughter. The reason for this is

high levels of fluoride can interfere with reproduction, milk production

and the general health of the breeding stock/dairy cows.

"Safe levels of fluoride in the diet dry matter for finishing [slaughter]

cattle are no more than 100 ppm (0.01 percent) and not more than 40 ppm

(0.004 percent) for animals to be kept in the breeding herd."

http://muextension.missouri.edu/explore/ag...nsci/g02081.htm

"Tolerance levels have been identified for domesticated animals, with the

lowest values for dairy cattle at 30 mg/kg feed or 2.5 mg/litre

drinking-water. . . Symptoms of fluoride toxicity include emaciation,

stiffness of joints and abnormal teeth and bones. Other effects include

lowered milk production and detrimental effects on the reproductive

capacity of animals."

http://www.inchem.org/documents/ehc/ehc/ehc227.htm

It seems that pets fall into the lower end of the 'safe limit' priorities

along with farm animals bred for slaughter - all regulations for levels of

undesirable constituents of mineral supplements were developed with

commercial agricultural ends in mind - profitability and cost saving for

the farmer or rancher.

Unfortunately, pets are not considered an agricultural commodity and the

agricultural standards are simply accepted without reservation by

veterinarians for all animals. They do not factor in the fact that pets are

pets and their owners are fond of them, and people want to keep them alive

and healthy for as long as possible. People's pets are not just nameless

cash producing commodities that either go to slaughter or are put-down when

they no longer can produce milk or offspring.

While, volumes of research has been done on pigs, sheep goats, chickens and

cattle with regard to adverse health effects from fluoride, there is very

little information about pets such as dogs and cats. Consequently, it is

safe to assume that many of dogs and cats who appear to be suffering with

arthritis/dysplasia, spinal deformities, etc. may have actually developed

skeletal fluorosis. The veterinarians don't have a clue that fluorosis

might be the problem.

It appears that most veterinarians are completely unaware of the fact that

there are cat and dog foods contain high fluoride levels and the physical

problems that it can cause your pet dog or cat.

Researchers are looking at many of the health problems as genetic

abbhorations rather than toxicant related conditions such as skeletal

fluorosis from high levels of fluoride contained in pet foods. While a

particular breed may be genetically predisposed to those health problems,

the contaminants in the feed may prematurely trigger the events or even

make them more pronounced at a young age.

The addition of mineral supplements which contain high levels of fluoride

is not a conspiracy, but plain old ignorance - your pet is simply in the

same category as a farm animal bred for slaughter - no one has ever

adequately investigated the long-term effects of fluoride intake on

domestic pets or its impact on specific breeds.

While they have know that certain breeds are genetically predisposed to hip

dysplasia (osteoarthritis), osteosarcoma, kidney dysfunction, etc., no one

has done research to determine if the high levels of fluoride in their feed

may exacerbate or even be the catalyst in triggering these adverse events.

Hip dysplasia is actually a form of arthritis of the hip bones. Most of

the dogs and cats that are genetically predisposed to dysplasia develop

the condition before they are two years old. However, dysplasia may well be

misdiagnosed and is actually skeletal fluorosis - but veterinarians have

not looked at this possibility because they haven't thought outside of the

agricultural nutrition box.

The primary source of the fluoride in pet foods is from the added mineral

supplements: defluorinated phosphate rock (which still retains some

fluoride and is found in more expensive pet foods), raw soft phosphate

rock, mono and tricalcium phosphate (made from a mixture of phosphoric acid

and calcium carbonate). The less expensive the dog food, probably, the

higher the fluoride levels because they would use .

Raw phosphate, mainly because of it's fluoride content (3% -4%) is most

physically damaging animal mineral supplement because it is not processed,

the least expensive. These facts have been known since the 1920s in early

animal nutritional research of fluorine in animal nutrition.

Manufacturers are not required to list the fluoride of contaminant levels

in pet food.

Could it be, that by simply changing the mineral supplements added to dog

and cat foods, many of the maladies your pet may suffer from can be

virtually eliminated or delayed until much later in life.

Visit this site http://www.dogpack.com/health/healthproblems.htm and do

some of your own research by entering "fluoride" or "fluorine*" with the

problem into an internet search.

From my research, I would suggest purchasing meat from the butcher, and if

the animal needs mineral supplements - give them the same quality

supplement that you would take yourself.

Also see: http://www.npwa.freeserve.co.uk/pollution.htm for more

information about phosphate rock.

* In animal nutrition, 'fluoride' is more commonly referred to as

'fluorine'.

ENDS.

George Glasser

Press Officer/Water Quality Advisor

National Pure Water Association

http://www.npwa.freeserve.co.uk/fluoride.html
 

Welcome to Dog Forum!

Join our vibrant online community dedicated to all things canine. Whether you're a seasoned owner or new to the world of dogs, our forum is your go-to hub for sharing stories, seeking advice, and connecting with fellow dog lovers. From training tips to health concerns, we cover it all. Register now and unleash the full potential of your dog-loving experience!

Login or Register
Back
Top