Windsor Critique

[jthatton]

Join our free community today.

Connect with other like-minded dog lovers!

Login or Register

I have just read Patsy Gilmour's critique of Whippets at Windsor ) in "Our Dogs" newspaper. What a refreshing change to read an informative summary written in plain English that gives constructive feedback as well as complimenting the dogs. I feel as if I was almost at the Show. Also haven't had to wait months for a critique or have it never appear. Where is the critique for the dogs at Crufts from 4 months ago? )

James

 

[maggie217]

I have just read Patsy Gilmour's critique of Whippets at Windsor )   in "Our Dogs" newspaper. What a refreshing change to read an informative summary written in plain English that gives constructive feedback as well as complimenting the dogs. I feel as if I was almost at the Show. Also haven't had to wait months for a critique or have it never appear. Where is the critique for the dogs at Crufts from 4 months ago? )
James

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

​

I agree with you. And published in Dog World the week before, only days after the show. :thumbsup:

Pauline

 

[rls22]

I very much enjoyed reading the Windsor critique. It is also nice to see why

the first dog was preferred to the second placed dog. :thumbsup:

 

[anniewhippet]

I very much enjoyed reading the Windsor critique.  It is also nice to see why the first dog was preferred to the second placed dog.  :thumbsup:

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

​

:- " Although I have a slightly biased view I have to agree that it is the type of critique that 'paints a picture' in words. one perhaps to learn from?.

 

[bertha]

The advantage of email!!!!!!!! If you email a critique it is printed so much quicker. Don't know why, I have in the past faxed them and they still take ages to go into print.

On a different tack, has Gay Robertsons critique been in Our Dogs yet? In Dog World, you would think Our Dogs would have done it with the photos Dewerstone took!!!!!!!!

:cheers:

 

[JAX]

Morag who did Crufts has been asked and her reasons for not yet doing it were told to me and she will be doing it in due course , :cheers:

 

[doris]

:- " Although I have a slightly biased view I

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

​

Really? Why's that . . . . . . . ? :- " :thumbsup: :lol: